Ballpark, Old Fashioned, Spicy and Horseradish deli mustard
Mix and match · four flavors

Build your own box.

Two jars or four, mixed however you like. Stone-milled in small batches, boxed by hand and out the door in 48 hours.

Box of 2 — $20Box of 4 — $36

Free shipping. Every box. Always.

No minimum · No code
Mix and match · four flavors

Point at what you want... just like at the counter.

Repeats welcome

Ballpark

For the dog & the burger8 oz

Clean and creamy, seven ingredients plus water. The hot dog mustard.

Horseradish

For pastrami & beef8 oz

Sharp Wisconsin horseradish. Built for pastrami and beef.

Old Fashioned

For the deli board8 oz

Whole seeds that pop, warm celery seed. The deli board jar.

Spicy

For the heat-seekers8 oz

Lots of heat, a little sweet. Pretzels do not stand a chance.

Choose quantities
Your order ticket
  • Free shipping, always
  • Ships in 48 hours
Finish your box
Packed the day you order

Small-batch runs, boxed by hand, out the door within 48 hours.

A pairing card in the box

What to put each mustard on, written by the people who mill it.

If a jar misses, we refund it

Email us within 30 days. We refund that jar and you keep the rest.

Before you build

Can I put four of the same flavor in one box?

Yes. The box counts jars, not flavors. Four Ballpark is a valid box of four.

What does the box of 4 save me?

Jars are $10 each on their own. A box of four is $36, so you save $4. Shipping is free either way.

Is this a subscription?

No. One box, one charge. Reorder when you run out.

How long does an open jar keep?

Refrigerate after opening and use within three months. Unopened jars hold two years.