Deli-made · Small batch since 2008

Like mustard?
We love it.

Four deli mustards, milled by hand in small batches since 2008. Ballpark, Old Fashioned, Spicy, Horseradish — in a jar you get to keep.

Order hereShop all
Free shipping Vegan Kosher Gluten-free Made in USA
Free shipping Caplansky's four deli mustards
From the founder

“I pour my heart and soul into these jars”

Same recipes I made at the deli, by hand, no shortcuts. Taste it once and you will know why people kept asking for a jar.

Zane Caplansky, founder
3× Silver · World-Wide Mustard Competition · 2022–2024 Also on shelves at butcher shops & gourmet grocers
The lineup

Meet the four.

Each one is milled in small batches and built for a job. Mix any of them into a 2-pack ($20) or a 4-pack ($36).

Caplansky's Ballpark deli mustard
For the dog & the burger

Ballpark

Mix into any box

Clean, pure, and simple. Seven ingredients plus water, no filler. Thick, creamy, and made for falling back in love with a hot dog.

View product →
Caplansky's Horseradish deli mustard
For pastrami & beef

Horseradish

Mix into any box

Our classic deli mustard. Sharp but not overpowering. Wisconsin horseradish brings out the best in beef, brats, and burgers.

View product →
Caplansky's Old Fashioned deli mustard
For the deli board

Old Fashioned

Mix into any box

The caviar of mustard. Whole seeds that pop and crunch, with the warm note of celery seed. Coarse, grainy, unlike anything else.

View product →
Caplansky's Spicy deli mustard
For the heat-seekers

Spicy

Mix into any box

Fireworks in your mouth. Lots of heat with a little sweet. Dunk a pretzel or schmear it across the sandwich.

View product →
Mix and match · four flavors

Your mustard, your mix.

Ballpark

For the dog & the burger8 oz

Clean and creamy, seven ingredients plus water. The hot dog mustard.

Horseradish

For pastrami & beef8 oz

Sharp Wisconsin horseradish. Built for pastrami and beef.

Old Fashioned

For the deli board8 oz

Whole seeds that pop, warm celery seed. The deli board jar.

Spicy

For the heat-seekers8 oz

Lots of heat, a little sweet. Pretzels do not stand a chance.

Choose quantities
Your order ticket
  • Free shipping, always
  • Ships in 48 hours
Zane Caplansky
Toronto · Since 2008

It started with
a sandwich he
never got.

A promised smoked-meat sandwich from Montreal never showed up. So Zane Caplansky taught himself to make his own — and the mustard came along for the ride. He made everything by hand. Still does.

Zane CaplanskyFounder
Read the story
From the table

Don't take our word for it.

Super tasty and tons of body. Makes others seem bland.
Ron
Done with bland
I consider myself a bit of a mustard connoisseur and I must say, this is the best darn mustard on the market.
Caroline
Mustard connoisseur
Bought as a birthday gift for my dad who loves mustard. The horseradish mustard in this set is his. He says it's the best mustard he's ever had.
M. M. Wright
Gift-giver, allegedly
Milled by hand

Small batches in a real kitchen since 2008. No factory line.

Nothing to hide

Vegan, kosher, gluten-free, GMO-free. Ballpark is seven ingredients, plus water.

Free shipping, always

Every US order, no minimum. Packed flat and shipped to your door.