The whole counter

Shop all mustard.

Four small-batch mustards, ready-made pairs, and a box you build yourself.

For someone lucky, or for you

Box of 2 $20 · Box of 4 $36

Choose the flavors you want. We pack them together and ship them in one box.

For the dog & the burger

Mix into any box

Clean, pure, and simple. Seven ingredients plus water, no filler. Thick, creamy, and made for falling back in love with a hot dog.

For pastrami & beef

Mix into any box

Our classic deli mustard. Sharp but not overpowering. Wisconsin horseradish brings out the best in beef, brats, and burgers.

The flagship

Two ready-made duos. Each one is a box of 2 for $20.

For the deli board

Mix into any box

The caviar of mustard. Whole seeds that pop and crunch, with the warm note of celery seed. Coarse, grainy, unlike anything else.

For the heat-seekers

Mix into any box

Fireworks in your mouth. Lots of heat with a little sweet. Dunk a pretzel or schmear it across the sandwich.