Shipping
Where do you ship?
Anywhere in the US, and shipping is free on every order with no minimum. Jars are packed snug; breakage gets replaced, no questions.
How long does it take?
Orders leave the kitchen within 2 business days and typically arrive in 3–5.
Do you ship to Canada?
Canada has its own store — same mustard, Canadian prices. Shop the Canadian site.
Product
What's actually in the jar?
Mustard seed, vinegar, salt, and the spices each flavor needs. Everything is vegan, kosher, gluten-free, and GMO-free. Ballpark is seven ingredients. Eight if you count water, which we don't.
How long does a jar last?
Unopened, about two years. Opened and refrigerated, months — though no jar has ever survived that long around here.
Which one should I start with?
Ballpark if you want the crowd-pleaser, Old Fashioned if you're a texture person, Horseradish for smoked meat, Spicy if you like fireworks. Or skip the decision and build a box.
Ordering
Can I mix flavors in a box?
That's the whole idea. Box of 2 or Box of 4, any combination — four Spicys is a legitimate life choice.
Is there a gift option?
The Gift Box: all four flavors, wrapped, with a card.
Something wrong with my order?
Write us at mustard@caplanskys.com and a human answers.